REVIEW PAPER
A nuanced ethic for live kidney donations
More details
Hide details
1
Yeshivah of Flatbush, Brooklyn, NY, USA
2
Maimonides Medical Center, Brooklyn, NY, USA
Submission date: 2014-02-05
Acceptance date: 2014-07-16
Online publication date: 2014-08-19
Publication date: 2020-04-06
Corresponding author
Joel B. Wolowelsky
Yeshivah of Flatbush, 1609 Avenue J, Brooklyn, NY 11230, USA. Tel.: +1 7183771100.
Pol. Ann. Med. 2014;21(2):143-146
KEYWORDS
ABSTRACT
Introduction:
Like other countries, Poland relies on the altruism of potential kidney donors but has an insufficient number of organs available to meet the growing need for organ transplantation.
Aim:
We investigate the ethics of non-altruistic kidney donations from the perspective of Jewish Medical Ethics, and consider how that ethic might work to alleviate the shortage in donations currently experienced by Poland and other countries.
Discussion:
Jewish medical ethics outlines a nuanced response to this shortage, suggesting that the requirement for organs to be donated without any commercial consideration may be modified to allow compensating an organ donor for his or her time, discomfort, inconvenience and recovery. Compensating an organ donor is fully consistent with traditional Judaism's moral code and does not detract from the ethical quality of the donation.
Conclusions:
While non-altruistic sale of kidneys might be theoretically acceptable, it requires creating a state system to insure that potential donors are properly informed and not exploited; that medical screening and support of the donors to insure that their health is not permanently endangered is provided; that vulnerable potential donors are protected; and that payments are regulated so that they reasonably reflect compensation for pain and suffering.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
None declared.
REFERENCES (21)
1.
Address of the Holy Father John Paul II on 29 August 2009 to the 18th International Congress of the Transplantation Society.
http://www.vatican.va/holy_fat... [accessed: 08.04.14].
2.
Milaniak I, Przybylowski P, Rużyczka EW, Wierzbicki K, Sadowski J. The opinions of young people on paid organ donation. Organs Tissues Cells. 2012;15:32–38.
3.
Wulman L. A history of Jewish physicians in Poland. In: Falstein L, ed. In: The martyrdom of Jewish physicians in Poland. New York: Exposition Press; 1963.
4.
Pogonowski IO. Jews in Poland: a documentary history. New York, USA: Hippocrene Books; 1993:27–28.
5.
Ohry-Kossoy K, Ohry A. Dedicated physicians in the face of diversity: the Association of Jewish Physicians (ZLRP) and Jewish Health Organization (TOZ) in Poland (1921–1941). Polin: Stud Polish Jewry. 2013;25:455–462.
7.
Ibn Zimra D. Teshuvot ha-Radbaz, III:627 [in Hebrew].
8.
Yosef O. Yabia Omer, 9. Hoshen Mispat;12 [in Hebrew].
9.
Goren SH. Torat HaRefuah. Jerusalem. 2000;147.
10.
Abraham AS. Nishmat Avraham, 4. Hoshen Mispat;420(3):1 [in Hebrew].
11.
Shafran Y. Selling organs – values and halakah. HaTsofeh. 1996;4 [in Hebrew].
12.
Lau YM. Selling organs for transplantation. Tehumin. 1998;18:125 [in Hebrew].
13.
Rapoport J, Kagan A, Friedlaender MM. Legalizing the sale of kidneys for transplantation: suggested guidelines. Isr Med Assoc J. 2002;4(12):1132–1134.
14.
Steinberg A. Compensation for kidney donation: a price worth paying. Isr Med Assoc J. 2002;4(12):1139–1140.
15.
Warburg R. Renal transplantation: living donors and markets for body parts-Halakha in concert with halakhic policy or public policy? Tradition. 2007;40(2):14–48.
16.
Wilkenson S. Commodification arguments for the legal prohibition of organ sale. Health Care Anal. 2000;8:189.
17.
Radcliffe-Richards JL, Daar AS, Guttman RD, et al. The case for allowing kidney sales. Lancet. 1998;351:1950.
18.
Halpern SD, Raz A, Kohn R, Asch DA, Reese P. Regulated payments for living kidney donation: an empirical assessment of the ethical concerns. Ann Intern Med. 2010;152(6):358–365.
19.
Goodwin M. The veneer of altruism. Virtual Mentor. 2012;14(3):256–263.
20.
Perenc L, Radochonski M, Radochonski A. Knowledge and attitudes of Polish university students toward organ donation and transplantation. Psychol Health Med. 2012;17(6):667–673.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/1354....
21.
Kosieradzki M, Czerwinski J, Jakubowska-Winecka A, et al. Partnership for transplantation: a new initiative to increase deceased organ donation in Poland. Transplant Proc. 2012;44(7):2176–2177.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.tr....